August, 2001

 

Costa Rica:  From Banana Republic to Oil Republic?



Oil exploration would threaten Costa Rica's diverse coastal and marine life, including coral reefs, sea turtles, tropical rainforests, mangroves, wetlands and the local cultures of the Caribbean coast 

By Margaret Thompson & María Suárez Toro

The search for "black gold" in Costa Rica is nothing new, leading to few results in the past.  Furthermore, global discussions of the dangers of global warming have made it clear the need to reduce fuel combustion and emissions.  Despite these circumstances,  the government of Costa Rica has recently given concessions to U.S. oil corporations for oil exploration and possible exploitation.  Pressure for new sources of oil from the new U.S. presidential administration whose ties to the oil industry go far back and deep have helped fuel such developments. 
 


A banner posted in Talamanca that says:
"[Wildlife] Refuge Gandoca-Manzanillo 
says no to petroleum contamination"
But strong resistance from local communities along the Atlantic Coast of Costa Rica who would be directly affected by oil exploitation have forced both the government and oil companies to stop temporarily their concerted efforts to exploit the natural resources of this world renowned tropical paradise.

But the present struggle is only the beginning.  According to Alicia Casas of OilWatch/Costa Rica, the struggle is not just a local one nor is it close to being over.   
 

 

According to Alicia, “What oil does is allow us to take an x-ray and examine closely the kind of society in which we live, the power of corporations, the power of certain industrialized societies over our resources, over our human rights and our future.” 
 

Opponents of oil development march in the annual parade in Limón for International Worker´s Day on May 1, 2001.  Above left, the banner says, "The South Caribbean defends fishing and eco-tourism.  No to the oil companies!"  The banner on the right declares, "Fishermen/women of Limon say no to the oil companies!"

 

Listen to a protest song about oil development by Boy-Boy, a resident of Puerto Viejo:

Click to listen

 

Boy-Boy

Thus the struggle over oil in the country serves as a microcosm for what has become a power struggle in many places around the world involving transnational corporations, national governments, international covenants and treaties on the environment and climate change, energy demands and policies of industrialized nations, and efforts by local communities to establish their own autonomy in exploring models of sustainable development that often conflict with projects of these broader powers. 

Costa Rica's Global Image of Environmental Protection & Sustainable Development 
 
Costa Rica is renowned worldwide for its rich biodiversity in both the rainforests and marine coastal areas, with numerous endangered and endemic species not found anywhere in the world.  The area is also home to numerous indigenous peoples and other cultural groups whose livelihoods of fishing and eco-tourism would be greatly threatened by oil exploration.  Costa Rica also has an image worldwide of a strong commitment to protecting this biodiversity through national parks, wildlife refuges and indigenous reserves as part of a model of sustainable development, as well as its participation in international covenants and treaties on the environment and indigenous peoples. 
A young BriBri boy displays an iguana 
from his family's iguana farm in Talamanca

These international agreements such as the 1992 Declaration of Rio about the environment and development, and the Convention on Climatic Change in 1993 and its Kyoto Protocol in 1997 call for the stabilization of the global climate through the reduction of its fuel combustion.  The Kyoto Protocol commits all governments to reduce their emissions by 5.7% in relationship to what they emitted in 1990.  Some of the main countries that consume the most fuel such as the United States, Australia and Japan, refused to implement this measure.  Governments that signed the Convention on Climatic Change, including Costa Rica, should be investing their resources in search of new forms of production and consumption of energy that do not affect the environment and the health of people. 

One example of efforts to develop alternative energy sources in Costa Rica are three geothermal energy production plants at the sites of some of the country's volcanoes.  However, in the midst of these efforts in the country to protect the environment and the health of its inhabitants, the last three presidential administrations have put up blocks of exploration for sale to the big international companies that are desperately searching for new sources of  oil despite the consequences.

Likewise within this global context, the oil companies should be dedicating their multimillion dollar resources to create alternative clean sources of energy, but are instead using their power and influence over governments to continue putting their thirst for profits above those of humanity and the survival of the planet.  And Costa Rica is a perfect example of this quest for profits at the expense of the local inhabitants.

Image Tarnished by Government Oil Concessions
Starting in 1997, the Costa Rican government began looking for foreign investors in its oil reserves.  The country had been divided into 22 blocks and were posted for bids to foreign oil companies.  In 1998, the government granted concessions or contracts to MKJ-Explorations of Louisiana to explore and eventually exploit oil in four blocks located within the Costa Rican Atlantic coastal area, totalling 5634 square kilometers.  Later 80% were sold to Harken Energy Corporation of Texas, which currently does most of its oil drilling in Colombia

The company was in the news a lot last year during the ultimately successful campaign of George W. Bush as US President, because for many years he was a principle investor, owner and employee of Harken.  This connection is just one of many of Bush's close ties to the oil industry, which was evident in his recent energy plan that calls for more exploration and exploitation of nonrenewable energy resources such as oil, thus creating a global backdrop for the struggle over oil exploration in Costa Rica. 

Local opposition to this latest oil exploration plan in Costa Rica has come from a wide variety of local development and tourism associations, small agricultural growers, fishermen's groups, NGOs, and other community groups, who feared the disastrous impact of this oil exploration on their lives and livelihoods.  They formed a coalition called ADELA (Accion de Lucha Antipetrolera--Action of Anti-Petroleum Struggle) and organized to oppose the government and oil companies' efforts.  ADELA filed a lawsuit with the Costa Rica Supreme Constitutional Court claiming that that the government had violated the local population's rights to prior consultation and participation in the process, which succeeded in blocking oil exploration in the indigenous reserves, but allowed the company to continue its exploration efforts in offshore drilling near the ports of Limon and Moin.   And more recently the group received international support for its struggle including an independent assessment of Harken's environmental impact study that revealed serious flaws in that study.

This report features the voices of women, the communities affected by the first private concession, the local controversy, and the regional and international exploitation of oil.

Other features in this report:

What YOU can do to support opposition to oil development in Costa Rica

As part of an international campaign, Global Response has issued an action alert asking that people write to the President of Costa Rica and also the CEO of Harken Energy Corporation, expressing their opposition to offshore oil drilling along the Atlantic Coast of Costa Rica, as well as other oil development projects in this  country. 

For more information, contact ADELA (Accion de Lucha Antipetrolera--Action of Anti-Petroleum Struggle) through their web page at:  www.cosmovisiones.com/adela.

For more information on OilWatch/Costa Rica, see their website at:  www.cosmovisiones.com/oilwatch, or write:  oilwatch@sol.racsa.co.cr.   Or for information on the international OilWatch campaign, contact Project Underground at: www.moles.org.

The legal work is being promoted through the Environmental Lawyers Alliance Worldwide (ELAW), who may be contacted through Emily Yozell at:  eyozell@sol.racsa.co.cr.